
Getty Images
Oct. 7, 2026
How should practices handle cell phone use? The cell phone policy debate comes down to whether tighter restrictions that keep staff fully present with patients or a more flexible approach that trusts employees to self-manage is best. The Divide, a point/counterpoint series from Review of Optometric Business, explores different sides of the conversation.
Quick summary:
- Kelly Allen, CPO: A structured cell phone policy protects patient privacy, supports professionalism and allows only limited, urgent personal use.
- Peter Bui, OD: A cell phone policy matters, but the real challenge is enforcing it without wasting energy or damaging team morale.
- Aaron Banta, OD: Keeping phones out of sight helps staff stay fully present, reinforcing a patient-first culture and stronger customer service.
- Delilah Yousef, OD, FAAO: A relaxed but clear-headed approach to cell phone use allows for flexibility for important needs while maintaining firm boundaries around professionalism.
A Team-Driven Cell Phone Policy That Supports Patient Care
Kelly Allen
By Kelly Allen, CPO
In 2025, our practice revamped its cell phone policy. Our previous policy was outdated and probably written before smartphones existed. The included rules were not very relevant, and the policy wasn’t easily enforced because it was so antiquated.
Since the previous policy was vague, some staff used their phones too much. Others didn’t use them at all. This caused a rift within the team.
We acknowledged the elephant in the room. We asked for volunteers to help draft a new cell phone policy. Their input was important. We wanted the staff to feel empowered to write a policy that was fair and that they felt comfortable with. This also allowed us to say, if you don’t volunteer for the committee, you can’t complain about the final policy!
We gave them time during staff meetings to work on the policy. Our guidelines were that the policy must be HIPAA compliant and must NOT interfere with patient care.
After a couple of meetings, the staff volunteers presented their proposal to the admin team. Then, we condensed their suggestions, finalized it and added it to our office handbook.
Iowa EyeCare recognizes that cell phones and mobile devices are part of modern life and may be necessary tools for communication. This policy is intended to support urgent and responsible phone use while protecting patient privacy, safety and professionalism in the workplace.
This policy applies to all staff, including clinical employees who provide direct patient care and administrative/support staff who help operate the practice outside of direct patient interaction.
Here are some details from our policy.
GENERAL USE
Cell phone use is prohibited in patient care areas and in the line of sight of patients. All use must remain HIPAA-compliant and may not interfere with patient care or team operations. Iowa EyeCare reserves the right to monitor phone use and take disciplinary action when needed.
CLINICAL STAFF
Clinical employees should silence or vibrate their phones during work hours. Non-leadership staff are encouraged to keep phones stored with personal belongings. If a phone is not stowed away, it must remain face down, out of view of patients, and should not be carried on the person. Staff may check notifications periodically, but only sparingly and when patient care is not actively underway.
LEADERSHIP AND SUPPORT STAFF
Leadership and designated non-clinical support staff may use phones for work-related purposes, preferably out of patient view. These employees may keep phones on their desks, silenced or on vibrate.
PERSONAL USE LIMITS
Personal calls and texting should be limited to urgent or emergency matters outside of scheduled breaks. Social media and games are prohibited during paid work time. Each office will designate “check zones,” such as break rooms or leadership-approved non-patient areas, for brief personal use of no more than five minutes.
ENFORCEMENT
Violations may result in verbal warnings, written warnings, a performance improvement plan or termination, depending on severity. Iowa EyeCare values privacy and will not confiscate personal phones, though employees may be asked to stow them if policy is not followed.
Kelly Allen, CPO, is the director of operations at Iowa EyeCare with locations in Cedar Rapids, Hiawatha, Marion and Robins, Iowa. To contact her: kallen@iowaeyecare.com
Do you have a topic you want to discuss on The Divide? Email us about a point/counterpoint conversation.
Managing Cell Phone Use Without Micromanaging
Dr. Peter Bui
By Peter Bui, OD
We have a cell phone policy which requires staff to keep their phones in their purses or in their desk drawer and do not allow usage of personal cell phones when they are on the clock. If they must make a phone call, then they will need to clock out and make the personal call.
Does the staff really follow the policy to the T? Am I even able to enforce this policy? The answer is no to both questions.
WHY WE KEEP THE POLICY
We have a policy in place to let staff know where we stand on cell phone usage, but it is realistically impossible to enforce the policy without spending too much of your energy and breaking down team morale. I understand staff need to check their text messages and email throughout the day for important messages. Even I sometimes text and call them during business hours.
WHEN IT BECOMES A PROBLEM
I only speak up about cell phone usage when it’s excessive, such as staff scrolling through social media or staring at their phone for more than a few minutes. I find it more productive to use your time and energy on making the office work better than to micromanage cell phone usage.
I find staff who are always on their phones are the least productive ones, and they make the most mistakes, so it’s better to fire them than to spend your energy micromanaging their cell phone usage.
Peter Bui, OD, is the owner of Omnivision Eye Care in Carrollton, Texas, and Lighthouse Eye Care in Plano, Texas. To contact him: t.bui.od@omnivisioneye.com
Do you have a topic you want to discuss on The Divide? Email us about a point/counterpoint conversation.
Sometimes The Old Ways are the Best Ways
Dr. Aaron Banta
By Aaron Banta, OD
The older I get, the more I find myself identifying with that sentiment, especially when it comes to customer service.
I recently visited a local shop to get a piece of equipment serviced. When I walked in, two men were behind the counter. One was helping a customer, and the other was scrolling aimlessly on his phone. The busy employee immediately looked up, acknowledged me, and said he’d be right with me. The second didn’t even glance my way. I waited at the counter until the first employee finished. Once he identified what I needed, he moved over to his coworker’s station, muttering an irritated “excuse me” to access the computer. Without ever looking up from his screen or acknowledging either of us, the second agent simply slid out of the way and kept right on scrolling.
The shift in our economy toward automated shopping, labor shortages, and tighter margins has left many consumers feeling like a burden rather than a priority. In the eyecare industry, there are certainly more frictionless ways to get eyewear than my office and ours is certainly not the least expensive clinic in town. To compete, we must differentiate ourselves through exceptional care and an unforgettable patient experience. As such, our team constantly focuses on the importance of being fully present for our patients. The primary mission of our team is to create memorable experiences for our guests and we simply cannot do that without looking them in the whites of their eyes.
PRESENT, NOT DISTRACTED
Let’s face it; we’re all addicted to our phones. The perceived need to be constantly connected to the world has resulted in us spending more time responding to push notifications and doom scrolling than truly connecting with people. That’s why our company policy requires our team to leave their cell phones in their lockers when they clock-in to work. Beyond preventing productivity slumps, this policy signals to patients that they are our first and only priority. Not allowing our team to have their phones is counter-cultural, and new hires often push back initially. However, anyone who buys into our core values quickly sees the value of the policy.
RESPECT GOES BOTH WAYS
It’s also important to us that our teammates feel like they’re being treated as professionals: we do not micro-manage breaks, and team members can step into the break room whenever they need to handle personal matters or reach their children. We allow managers to carry phones only to receive call-out messages from staff. We also make reasonable exceptions to our no-phone policy whenever circumstances dictate.
Mature, professional relationships are two-way streets. Granting our team the respect and independence to self-manage their personal affairs also requires them to give their full attention to our patients and the mission of the office when they are on-the-clock. Every patient who walks through our front door is someone’s mother, father, son, or daughter and they deserve the very best experience we can give them. Eliminating the distraction of personal phones is one way we ensure we give that to them.
Aaron M. Banta, OD, is a co-owner of Center Vision Clinic in Kennewick, Washington. In addition to providing unparalleled patient care, his passions include team building, clinic culture development and optical management/sales strategies. He also serves as an adjunct clinical professor for Pacific University College of Optometry. To contact him: drbanta@centervisionclinic.org
Do you have a topic you want to discuss on The Divide? Email us about a point/counterpoint conversation.
Don’t Make It Weird: A Relaxed Cell Phone Policy That Works
Dr. Delilah Yousef
By Delilah Yousef, OD, FAAO
Cell phones are simply part of our lives. You can either fight it or accept it. Staff may need to wait for a doctor’s call, and many have children in school and need to be available if something happens. Or they might use social media for office-related tasks, like researching TikTok for ideas or drafts regarding an event promotion. The turnaround time is much quicker when they can just use their phones.
I do not want people to feel nervous about using their phones when it is for something important, but I also don’t want phone misuse to become a bigger issue than it needs to be.
CLEAR EXPECTATIONS
When staff go through the onboarding process, I tell them our policy. The only rule is that phones cannot be stationed visibly where a patient or I can see them. At the front desk, they must be hidden. That also means no phones in back pockets.
Phones can’t be on their desk; they must be in a drawer. I don’t want to hear vibrations, dings or even see it light up when I am at their desk for whatever reason I might need to be there. This will annoy me.
They know that when I am annoyed, the policy is most likely being reconsidered in my head. I don’t care if I see them on it because they know the rules: they can’t scroll social media or have a long text conversation, etc. I know my staff and their habits, and I can tell when someone is scrolling the second I look at them, so that’s easy to monitor.
“DON’T MAKE IT WEIRD”
Each new staff member receives a “please, don’t make this weird for us” talk.
This conversation addresses how I want to put my trust in them and not have to say something about cell phone usage. We try to avoid that awkward “put away your phone” talk. It’s weird to be a mom to them when I am their boss. It’s kind of a silly title for our conversation, but it really relaxes the staff regarding what constitutes a true “cell phone policy”. If I take it away, it was their choice not mine.
I will say, “It seems like you are choosing for me to make this weird and take away your cell phone privilege; let’s try again.” This is the first and only chance, and then they lose their privilege. I call it my “gentle parenting with a boundary talk,” and it seems to be working. With this policy in place for the past five years, I have NEVER had to say anything beyond this initial conversation.
A RELAXED POLICY REINFORCED BY STAFF
I also have my existing staff talk to new staff members, too. Having their peers assist in this step is helpful. They know that’s how we do things, how they personally look out for one another.
If an employee does their work and is reliable, I don’t care if they briefly look at their phone. We have a small office of 7. If it becomes a problem, their colleagues usually say, “Stop being on your phone so much or Dr. Yousef will get upset.” They look out for one another and prefer not to have a strict policy.
PROFESSIONALISM AND COURTESY
Our policy starts with one conversation. In our practice, that really drives the message home. It’s an exercise for the staff in showing courtesy to their peers, and they agree that cell phone usage outside of our guidelines can be distracting.
This approach keeps me from giving out repeated warnings and helps us work out any problems long before it’s an issue that I would notice.
Delilah Yousef, OD, FAAO, is the owner of Southwest Vision in Austin, Texas.
Do you have a topic you want to discuss on The Divide? Email us about a point/counterpoint conversation.
